Montauk Cottage (SOLD)

Montauk, the way it used to be.


This rare offering, one of the historic Association parcels in Ditch Plains is comprised of two dreamy acres tucked away down a long drive. This 1948 cottage has plenty of room for expansion. The 1,300 square-foot cottage has three bedrooms, two baths, living room with vaulted ceiling and wood-burning fireplace, a separate dining room and kitchen. A spacious patio off the dining room faces south, and there is ample room for a pool. The owners have a barn they were going to add to the property and possibly attach to the current cottage. The barn can be purchased separately. Possibilities abound in this scenic location—renovate and expand the existing cottage, add a pool, or build a new home.


Located a stone’s throw from world class surfing destination Ditch Plains Beach, and set high on a hill, the property has views of the ocean, Lake Montauk, and the Moorlands. There are a number of good breaks besides Ditch Plains although that is the most popular. Although Montauk and Long Island in general has 4 seasons (summer being the most popular), permanent residents surf throughout the year. This particular property is on a private dirt road that is a historic district with 7 houses each on beautiful properties that are called “the seven sisters.” Rarely does one come on the market for sale. New York City is a three-hour car ride away. The home sits 2.5 hours from JFK airport or 20 minutes from East Hampton Airport. If you fly private or by seaplane or helicopter, Montauk Airport is available five minutes away.

Pricing and Contact Information

$3,200,00 USD.

Jane Gill:  516-909-9591

Ed Patrowicz: 917-887-1189

Surf Properties

Inclusion in Surf Properties is a paid service for those listing, and a free viewing zone for surfers to browse for their dream surf home.

List your property:

T: (949) 361-0331